This week we were supposed to talk
about a time we witnessed an adult silence a child, or silenced them ourselves,
for pointing out someone's differences. The best situation I can remember was
when I was a child myself. We were at the zoo or somewhere you had to walk a
lot and I was tired. I saw a woman in a wheelchair and commented that she was
lucky because she could sit everywhere she went. My mother shushed me and said
don't talk like that.
Receiving this message opposed the
image I had been building regarding diversely abled people. See my older sister
has disabilities, and she looks a little different. We learned sign language so
we could communicate with her more effectively, but she was capable to do just
about everything else. Then suddenly my mother is telling me not to talk about
people that look visibly different than myself. My mother's response confused
me and really bothered me for some time afterwards, I remember thinking about
it multiple times growing up.
According to our course media, it is
important to intervene when incidents happen as well as being proactive (Laureate,
Race). My mother should have talked to me about what I said and how it could be
perceived by others. She could have helped me to understand that the woman is
not relaxing in her chair, she is working with her arms. If we were in a
classroom, a teacher may respond to a child saying this by introducing a game
or discussion in which images are used of diversely abled people doing positive,
and active, things (Laureate, Race). Another option in the classroom, as well
as at home, would be to use puppets for children to express themselves through
a third party (Laureate, Physical). Children's literature could also be used to
broaden children's understandings, but be wary of stereotypes within the books
as well as among the books you chose (Laureate, Physical).
Jen,
ReplyDeleteThank you for sharing that story, especially how it connected to your sister. If I had been in your situation, I probably would have been confused as well. I think that it is important that we are intentional in how we deal with children's curiosity so that we do not send mixed messages. That may not have been the most appropriate time for a discussion about it, but I think that it is important to acknowledge that curiosity and then have a talk later.
Thank you for explaining your situation with your sister. I could see how getting different messages about different disabilities could be confusing. I think that if your mom would have talked to you that you would have been more understanding from that point on. I think this is why as adults we need to have conversations with children as quickly as we can when something happens. It might not be that second, but on the ride home at least.
ReplyDelete